When geography becomes security, comfort becomes expectation, and history becomes something that happens to other people.
There is an old saying that has always fascinated me:
“A bee doesn’t waste its time explaining to a fly why honey is better than manure.”
It’s a rather crude analogy, but beneath the humor lies an interesting observation about human behavior. Two creatures can inhabit the same world, encounter the same opportunities, and yet be drawn toward entirely different things.
What one recognizes as valuable, the other may have little interest in pursuing. Human beings aren’t so different. We develop our understanding of the world through experience, education, culture, and personal convictions. Over time, those experiences become the foundation upon which we interpret almost everything around us. And sometimes that foundation becomes so familiar that we stop questioning whether it accurately reflects the world beyond our immediate surroundings.
I wonder whether Americans, perhaps more than many other populations, have developed a particularly interesting relationship with this phenomenon. Not because Americans are inherently less intelligent, less informed, or less capable of understanding global affairs. But because America’s historical experience has been remarkably different from that of much of the world.
And that difference matters.
The Blessing and Burden of Geography
Consider the geography of the United States. To our east lies the Atlantic Ocean. To our west, the Pacific. To our north, Canada. To our south, Mexico. We occupy an enormous continent blessed with natural resources, agricultural capacity, navigable waterways, and geographical advantages that have helped shape our economic and military development.
For much of our history, these advantages have provided a degree of separation from the conflicts that repeatedly devastated other regions. Europe endured centuries of territorial warfare, shifting borders, invading armies, and collapsing governments. The Middle East has experienced the rise and fall of empires, religious conflicts, foreign interventions, and political upheaval. Across Africa and Asia, generations have experienced colonialism, revolution, civil wars, occupations, and the consequences of geopolitical competition.
America has certainly experienced tremendous suffering of its own.
The Civil War nearly destroyed the Union. The Great Depression devastated families. Pearl Harbor demonstrated that oceans were not impenetrable barriers. September 11 reminded an entire generation that threats originating thousands of miles away could reach American soil.
Yet for most Americans alive today, foreign military occupation, widespread destruction from conventional warfare, and the collapse of national institutions remain experiences encountered through books, documentaries, and television screens.
They are things we study. Things we discuss. Things we watch happen somewhere else.
But what happens when generations grow accustomed to believing that the most serious consequences of global instability belong to other people?
When Experience Becomes Expectation
There is a psychological concept known as normalcy bias. Simply put, people tend to assume that the future will resemble the past, particularly when their personal experiences have been relatively stable. We wake up expecting electricity. We assume grocery stores will have food. We expect financial institutions to function, emergency services to respond, and government institutions to continue operating.
We make plans for next month, next year, and retirement based on the assumption that the fundamental structures supporting our lives will remain intact. Most of the time, these assumptions are reasonable. Societies could hardly function if everyone lived in constant anticipation of catastrophe. But there is a difference between reasonable confidence and unquestioned certainty.
Stability is something a society maintains. It is not something history guarantees.
The people living in powerful civilizations throughout history did not necessarily recognize that they were approaching periods of profound transformation. They went to work. Raised families. Conducted business. Argued about politics. Practiced their faith. Planned for their futures. Much as we do today.
The Roman Empire did not disappear in a single afternoon. Its western political structure weakened through a complicated combination of military, economic, political, and institutional pressures. Other nations and empires have undergone their own transformations, each shaped by circumstances unique to its time. Yet one recurring lesson remains. Power and prosperity do not eliminate vulnerability. They can sometimes make vulnerability more difficult to recognize.
The Cognitive Dissonance of American Security
Cognitive dissonance describes the psychological discomfort people may experience when confronted with conflicting beliefs, values, or behaviors. Consider three propositions: First, history demonstrates that powerful nations can decline, fracture, or undergo radical transformation. Second, the United States is a powerful nation. Third, the United States could never experience the kinds of national crises that have affected other civilizations.
Those beliefs do not fit together as comfortably as we might like. Something must give. We can reconsider our assumption of American invulnerability, or we can convince ourselves that America is somehow exempt from the historical forces that have affected other nations.
Often, the easier option is to preserve the belief that makes us comfortable. We tell ourselves that America is different. Our institutions are stronger. Our economy is larger. Our military is more capable. Our people would never allow such things to happen. Some of those observations reflect genuine American strengths.
But none establishes immunity from history. And this is where cognitive dissonance becomes particularly relevant.
When information threatens a deeply held assumption, we may spend more energy defending the assumption than evaluating the information.
The World Through an American Window
Imagine two people watching the same news report about political instability in a foreign country. One sees a distant tragedy. Another recognizes political and social patterns that have appeared elsewhere throughout history. A third dismisses the entire situation because it seems incompatible with their understanding of how modern societies function.
The event itself has not changed. The interpretation has. Our understanding of world events is influenced not only by what we know, but by what we believe is possible.
An individual who has experienced war, displacement, authoritarian government, or economic collapse may interpret early warning signs very differently from someone whose entire life has unfolded within a relatively stable society.
Neither perspective automatically guarantees an accurate conclusion. Experience can sharpen judgment, but it can also create biases of its own. Nevertheless, dismissing someone’s concerns simply because their experiences differ from ours can prevent us from learning lessons we have been fortunate enough not to experience firsthand.
There is a profound difference between knowing that something has happened and understanding that it could happen again. And perhaps an even greater difference between believing it could happen somewhere and accepting that it could happen here.
The Bee, the Fly, and the Problem of Certainty
This brings me back to that old saying about the bee and the fly. At first glance, the message seems straightforward. Why waste time explaining something valuable to someone who refuses to appreciate it? But human beings introduce a complication that the analogy doesn’t address.
What happens when both people believe they are the bee?
What happens when each person is absolutely convinced that their understanding represents the truth and that the other person simply refuses to recognize it? We see this constantly in discussions involving politics, religion, culture, economics, and international affairs.
People encounter information that challenges their worldview and immediately begin searching for reasons to reject it. Not necessarily because the information is false. But because accepting it might require reconsidering something they have believed for decades.
The reverse can also happen. People may embrace alarming claims because those claims reinforce their existing fears. Neither response represents careful reasoning. Wisdom requires more than defending what we already believe. It requires the willingness to examine why we believe it, what evidence supports it, and whether our conclusions remain justified when confronted with new information.
Sometimes the most dangerous form of ignorance isn’t a lack of knowledge. It is the certainty that we already know everything necessary.
When Global Events Become Local Consequences
The oceans that once provided America with considerable geographic separation have not disappeared. But the world has changed. International trade, financial systems, communications networks, energy markets, migration, and digital infrastructure connect nations in ways previous generations could scarcely imagine.
A war thousands of miles away can influence energy prices. A disruption in international shipping can affect American manufacturers and consumers. A financial crisis in one region can spread through interconnected markets. Cyberattacks can threaten infrastructure without a single foreign soldier crossing an American border. Ideological movements can circulate internationally through digital communications, although their influence and consequences vary greatly depending on the societies receiving them.
In other words, physical distance no longer guarantees practical separation.
America can remain geographically protected while becoming increasingly exposed to events occurring far beyond its borders.
Yet our psychological understanding of security may not have evolved at the same pace as our technological interconnectedness. We continue thinking in terms of distance even when the consequences of distant events can reach us almost immediately. And because those consequences often develop gradually, we may fail to recognize the connection until the effects become impossible to ignore.
A Biblical Perspective on Complacency
For Christians, there is another dimension worth considering. Scripture repeatedly addresses the danger of mistaking prosperity, strength, or temporary security for permanent protection. The ancient Israelites experienced periods of blessing, military success, and national stability. Yet their history also contains repeated warnings about pride, complacency, injustice, and the consequences of abandoning their responsibilities.
Those accounts were written within specific historical and covenantal contexts. The United States is not ancient Israel, nor should we casually assume that every biblical judgment against Israel applies directly to modern America. Nevertheless, the moral lessons concerning human pride and misplaced confidence remain relevant. Proverbs 16:18 reminds us:
“Pride goeth before destruction, and an haughty spirit before a fall.”
The warning is not that every prosperous nation is destined for destruction. It is that prosperity can encourage a dangerous kind of self-confidence when people begin believing their achievements place them beyond accountability or consequence. The same principle applies to individuals.
Success can make us grateful. Or it can make us complacent. Security can inspire responsible stewardship. Or it can convince us that preparation is unnecessary. The difference often lies in whether we recognize our advantages as responsibilities to preserve or privileges we assume will always exist.
The Danger of Waiting Until We Understand
One of the more troubling aspects of human behavior is our tendency to understand certain lessons only after experiencing their consequences. We know that financial instability can devastate families, yet people frequently postpone preparing for emergencies. We know that relationships require attention, yet sometimes recognize their importance only after they deteriorate. We know that political institutions require public trust, accountability, and participation, yet often take those institutions for granted until they begin to fail.
Nations can exhibit similar patterns. We study history while assuming that its most difficult lessons belong to the past. We observe international instability while convincing ourselves that geography, wealth, or military power will insulate us from comparable challenges. And when someone suggests that we examine the parallels, the response is frequently dismissal rather than curiosity.
Perhaps the greatest obstacle to recognizing a developing problem is not the absence of information. Perhaps it is our inability to reconcile that information with the world we have always known.
Learning Without Having to Suffer
There is an important distinction between awareness and fear. Recognizing that societies can experience profound disruption does not mean living in constant expectation of national catastrophe. Nor does examining historical parallels mean assuming that every modern disagreement signals an approaching collapse.
History does not repeat itself with mechanical precision. Circumstances change, institutions evolve, and human decisions influence outcomes. But history does offer something extraordinarily valuable. It allows us to learn from experiences we have not personally endured.
We do not need to experience a war to appreciate peace. We do not need to lose our freedoms to recognize their value. We do not need to witness the collapse of institutions to understand why maintaining them matters. And we should not need to experience the consequences of every global crisis before recognizing that events beyond our borders can affect our own lives.
The ability to learn without personally suffering the lesson may be one of humanity’s greatest intellectual advantages. Whether we choose to exercise that ability is another question.
It Could Happen Here
I love my country. I recognize the extraordinary advantages Americans have inherited, the sacrifices that helped establish and preserve those advantages, and the resilience our nation has demonstrated through difficult periods. But loving a country does not require believing it is invulnerable. In fact, I would argue the opposite.
A society that genuinely values what it possesses should be willing to examine what could threaten it.
That examination requires intellectual humility.
It requires acknowledging that other nations have histories worth studying, that unfamiliar experiences can offer valuable lessons, and that our own assumptions deserve the same scrutiny we apply to the beliefs of others. Perhaps the greatest danger of American exceptionalism is not the belief that America has accomplished extraordinary things.
It is allowing those accomplishments to become evidence, in our minds, that the ordinary lessons of human history no longer apply. Our oceans are vast. Our resources are abundant. Our institutions have endured. But geography is not a guarantee, prosperity is not permanence, and yesterday’s stability is not a promise about tomorrow.
Which brings me back, once again, to the bee and the fly. Perhaps the most important question isn’t whether we can convince someone else that honey is better. Perhaps it is whether we possess enough humility to recognize when our own preferences, assumptions, and experiences have prevented us from seeing what is directly in front of us. Because sometimes the greatest challenge isn’t convincing others to see the world differently.
It’s recognizing that the world may be very different from the one we’ve convinced ourselves exists.

Discover more from Troy P Zehnder
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.